Churches say there is no competition among us. I am not sure we always believe it.

The first Bruins vs. Canadiens game of the season is tonight. There are just three of them all season! Does the NHL need to add more rivalry games to its schedule?

We celebrate another church’s growth, but we also wonder whether some of those people used to attend ours. We pray for the church across town, but we compare attendance, buildings, worship, staff, preaching, giving, programs, and influence. We speak about the kingdom of God while quietly guarding our market share.

Our branding has trained us to see separate churches as separate companies.

Each congregation has a name, logo, culture, strategy, audience, and product. We identify what makes us different. We tell people why our church is a good fit. We build loyalty to our location, our leaders, our values, and how we do ministry.

Some local identity is healthy. Churches are real communities in real places, and no congregation can do everything. Traditions matter. Callings differ. One church may be deeply invested in recovery ministry while another serves immigrants, plants churches, cares for children, or offers a faithful presence in a rural community. Difference is not the problem.

Competition is.

Share

Paul did not describe the church as a collection of religious companies competing for consumers. He called us one body. In 1 Corinthians 12, there are many parts, many gifts, and many kinds of service, but one Spirit and one body. A hand does not become more successful when the foot struggles. An eye does not gain influence when the ear disappears.

If we are one body, another church’s fruit is not our loss. God doesn’t reward one church by punishing another.

Another pastor’s influence does not diminish our calling. Another congregation’s baptism is a reason to celebrate, even if the person once sat in our sanctuary. Another church reaching people we could not reach is not evidence that we failed. It may show the body is working.

Corporate brands need consumers to choose them instead of their competitors. The body of Christ gives itself away in love.

That difference reaches beyond how pastors relate to one another. It changes how Christians think about belonging.

If churches are competing brands, then the goal is to find the one that best matches our preferences.

If the church is a body, then the question is not simply, “Which place fits me?” It is also, “Where am I called to belong, serve, forgive, grow, and give myself away?”

Belonging to a body is different from attaching ourselves to a brand.

We can wear a brand without knowing anyone else who wears it. We can consume its content, attend its events, and recommend it to friends without ever being personally responsible for another human being. A body is more demanding. If one part suffers, the others suffer. If one part is missing, the whole body feels the absence.

The consumer church lets us remain replaceable. We can disappear, and someone else will fill the seat. The body of Christ says our presence matters—not because we help the numbers, but because we belong to one another.

This is why church competition is not just an ugly leadership habit. It is an ecclesiological problem. It tells the world that our local success matters more than our shared witness. It turns pastors into brand managers and Christians into customers moving between locations.

Jesus prayed that his people would be one. That unity does not require every church to merge, every pastor to agree on strategy, or every Christian tradition to lose its distinctives. It requires us to remember whose church this is.

It is not mine. It is not ours. It is Christ’s.

I’m glad when we recognize a local church and understand its calling. But the moment our brand becomes something we must defend against another part of Christ’s body, it has become too important. The moment our brand becomes the wink and nod that says, “This place is so much better than that place,” well, then we’ve really lost our way.

We don't need to erase every church name or pretend differences don't matter. We need the humility to hold those names loosely. No competition exists among us because there is no “us” and “them” within the body of Christ.

There is one Lord, one Spirit, one body, and one calling: to embody the life of Jesus together.

Leave a comment

Subscribe now

Nate Drye

Dear Church: We Are Not Competing Companies